Cal Raleigh Dethrones Aaron Judge as AL MVP Favorite After Injury Shake-Up

Despite Cal Raleigh’s prodigious home run season, especially for a catcher and a switch-hitter, Aaron Judge has been the favorite (and a significant one) all season to win the American League MVP Award.

Last week at BetOnline.ag, Judge was -700, which gave him an 87.5% likelihood of winning the award.

After the right elbow injury announcement, and subsequent trip to the 10-day injured list, coupled with two more home runs by Raleigh, the “Big Dumper” is now the AL MVP favorite.

American League MVP odds are fluid and subject to change. Here’s the direct link to real-time lines.

2025 American League MVP
Cal Raleigh	5/8	(-160)
Aaron Judge	6/5	(+120)
Tarik Skubal	40/1
Jose Ramirez	60/1
Bobby Witt Jr.	80/1
Byron Buxton	100/1
Nick Kurtz	100/1
Riley Greene	125/1
Junior Caminero	150/1