2024-25 NFL Coach of the Year Award Odds: MacDonald Favored, Mayo Rises After Week 1

By Luis September 10, 2024

0 Comments

2024-25 NFL Coach of the Year Award Odds: MacDonald Favored, Mayo Rises After Week 1

Jim Harbaugh’s return to the NFL started off strong, moving his odds for the 2024-25 NFL Coach of the Year (COTY) award from +1,000 to +800 following a Week 1 win. Harbaugh isn’t the only coach making moves on the odds board, with New England Patriots’ head coach Jerod Mayo also climbing after an impressive debut victory.

Currently the Seattle Seahawks’ head coach Mike MacDonald leads the pack with +700 odds to win coach of the year this season.

Other favorites:

Jim Harbaugh (+800)

Wherever Jim Harbaugh goes, success follows. After leading Michigan to a National Championship, Harbaugh is now tasked with turning around a Los Angeles Chargers team that finished a disappointing 5-11 last season.

His debut went according to plan, as the Chargers secured a significant division win over the Las Vegas Raiders, holding them to just 10 points. This win has kept Harbaugh at the forefront of the COTY race.

Matt Eberflus (+1400)

Despite a .294 winning percentage over two seasons as the Chicago Bears’ head coach, Matt Eberflus still carries optimism in Chicago.

The Bears managed a comeback in Week 1 after falling into a 17-0 deficit, thanks to two defensive touchdowns that helped secure a win for rookie QB Caleb Williams. However, Eberflus will need to spark offensive improvements if he wants to maintain his standing in the COTY conversation.

Big Mover: Jerod Mayo (+1000)

Jerod Mayo is making headlines after his debut as the head coach of the New England Patriots. A Week 1 victory over the Cincinnati Bengals has pushed Mayo into the Top 10 for COTY odds at FanDuel Sportsbook.

While Cincinnati was missing a top receiver, Mayo’s team capitalized with a goal-line stand and strong special teams performance to secure the win in the first game of the post-Belichick era. Whether the Patriots can maintain this momentum remains to be seen, but Mayo’s stock is rising quickly.

NFL 2024/25 Coach of the Year Odds at BetOnline

Coach	Odds
Mike Macdonald	+700
Jim Harbaugh	+800
Jerod Mayo	+1000
Demeco Ryans	+1400
Matt Eberflus	+1400
Mike Tomlin	+1400
Kevin O’Connell	+1400
Raheem Morris	+1600
Shane Steichen	+1600
Jonathan Gannon	+2000
Dan Campbell	+2000
Mike McDaniel	+2000
Matt LaFleur	+2200
Robert Saleh	+2500
Dave Canales	+2500
Brian Callahan	+2500
Sean Payton	+2800
Todd Bowles	+2800
Sean McVay	+4000
Antonio Pierce	+4000
Zac Taylor	+4000
Kyle Shanahan	+4000
Dan Quinn	+4000
Dennis Allen	+4000
Sean McDermott	+5000
Nick Sirianni	+5000
Mike McCarthy	+5000
Doug Pederson	+6600
John Harbaugh	+6600
Andy Reid	+6600
Brian Daboll	+10000
Kevin Stefanski	+10000

NFL Coach of the Year Trends

No Back-to-Back Winners: There has not been a back-to-back winner of the Coach of the Year award since Joe Gibbs in 1982 and 1983.
Multiple Winners: Thirteen coaches have won the COTY award multiple times, with three (Don Shula, Chuck Knox, Bill Belichick) winning it three or more times.
Below .500 Exception: Only one coach has won the COTY award despite his team finishing below .500 for the season (Jimmy Johnson in 1990).

The race for the 2024-25 NFL Coach of the Year is off to an intriguing start, with Jim Harbaugh leading the pack following a solid Week 1 win. However, Jerod Mayo’s rapid rise after his debut victory with the Patriots adds excitement to the competition.

As the season unfolds, keep an eye on how these coaches and others on the list navigate their teams through the challenges ahead.Jim Harbaugh’s return to the NFL started off strong, moving his odds for the 2024-25 NFL Coach of the Year (COTY) award from +1,000 to +800 following a Week 1 win. Harbaugh isn’t the only coach making moves on the odds board, with New England Patriots’ head coach Jerod Mayo also climbing after an impressive debut victory.