2025 NFL Comeback Player of the Year Odds: Hutchinson, McCaffrey, and Prescott Lead the Way

There were a lot of unhappy bettors after Joe Burrow took home Comeback Player of the Year honors over Sam Darnold in 2024. 

The Associated Press aimed to have the voters cast their lots for guys who had a great season after returning from injury, and they obliged (especially Mike Florio, who stirred the award pot initially), and it appears that “other circumstances” bit is now a thing of the past.

BetOnline.ag has released 2025 Comeback POY odds for the upcoming season, and the favorites are all coming back from injury. 

Aaron Rodgers is the only guy in the Top 10 who didn’t get injured last year. Don’t forget, Rodgers was the favorite for this award going into the 2024 season.

NFL Comeback Player of the Year odds are subject to change and will be updated in real-time on this page: https://betonline.ag/sportsbook/futures-and-props/nfl-player-futures/comeback-player-of-the-year   

2025 Comeback POY

Aidan Hutchinson          2/1

Christian McCaffrey       3/1

Dak Prescott                 7/2

Trevor Lawrence           4/1

J.J. McCarthy                10/1

Rashee Rice                  14/1

Aaron Rodgers              16/1

Maxx Crosby                 20/1

Derek Carr                    20/1

Stefon Diggs                 20/1

Brandon Aiyuk              22/1

Tank Dell                      25/1

Tua Tagovailoa              25/1

Kirk Cousins                  25/1

Chris Godwin                33/1

Anthony Richardson      33/1

Nick Chubb                   33/1

Daniel Jones                 33/1

Deshaun Watson           50/1

Chris Olave                   50/1

Rashid Shaheed             50/1

Rondale Moore             66/1

Marquise Brown           75/1

L’Jarius Sneed               75/1

Jaire Alexander             75/1

Dre Greenlaw               75/1

Demarcus Lawrence      75/1

Cooper Kupp                 75/1

Tyler Higbee                 75/1

Evan Engram                 100/1

Christian Kirk                100/1

Zack Moss                     100/1

Taysom Hill                   100/1

AJ Dillon                       100/1